-
How would you look at the 25 years
of nationalised banking from today's perspective ?
While supporting the financial and economic
structure of our country, banking itself has undergone evolutionary process
and revolutionary changes during last 25 years.The nationalisation of 14
major commercial banks in July, 1969 followed by six others in April, 1980
added a new dimension to the role of commercial banks as catalysts in promoting
the economic growth of the country. The banks were called upon to shoulder
new social responsibilities and there was a major change of traditional
concept of `class banking' to the new concept of `mass banking'.
The post nationalisation period
witnessed commercial banks spreading mostly in rural and semi urban areas-thus
reducing the density of banking coverage on reaching to the doorsteps of
common man and diversifying the credit flow towards priority sector, implementation
of a number of poverty alleviation schemes, setting up of employment generation
opportunities and professionalisation of bank management.
Consequently, banking has seen a
significant increase in the volume of deposit in relation to Gross Domestic
Product from 13% in 1969 to 38% in 1991 and increase in credit from 10%
to 25%. During the period, share of rural deposit increased from 3% to
15% and share of priority sector crossed 40% of net bank credit.
Thus this era was characterised
by the decline of private banking and the dominance of social control over
commercial banking.
Consolidation
The mid eighties saw the commercial
banks consolidate the gains of expansions. At this point of time, 90% of
the Commercial Banks were in the Public Sector and closely regulated in
all respects. Prices of assets and liabilities (rate of interest of deposits
and advances) were fixed by RBI, prices of services were fixed uniformly
by IBA, composition of assets were also some what fixed towards priority
sector lending, small loans etc. after meeting up CRR/SLR requirements.
Locations of branches were approved by RBI; salary structures were negotiated
by IBA and approved by the Government of India. In this way, commercial
autonomy in vital decisions was at its minimum and productivity and efficiency
were given low premium.
Reforms
As a result of the continuing financial
profligacy of the government along with close control on vital functions,
banking became dependent and inefficient in the early 1990s. It was a situation
that called for drastic changes in banking and financial sector if the
economic situation was to be brought under control. Partly as a result
of internal crisis precipitated by the Foreign Exchange shortfall and partly
as a result of external pressure emerging from global compulsions in the
financial sector, initiating sweeping reforms became a matter of survival.
To combat the situation, RBI introduced LERMS (liberalised Exchange Rate
Mechanism system) in 1991, which was the beginning of an era of freedom
to the banks in the history of Foreign Exchange transaction in a somewhat
limited manner.
In 1991, the Narasimham Committee
recommendations were a milestone in the direction of reforms and brought
about a total transformation in the banking sector. The radical measures
were :
-
Preparation of Balance Sheet of Banks
in a more transparent form
-
Introduction of capital adequacy norms.
-
Income recognition and asset classification
norms and provisioning on loan assets.
-
Partial deregulation of interest rates
on deposits and advances
-
Freedom of entry for private banks.
-
Permission to public sector banks to
approach the markets for raising their capital
-
Upgradation of technology (computerisation)
If we look at the reforms we shall observe
that they have basically two objectives viz.
-
Improving the customer service and thereby
making banking more competitive.
-
Improving bottom lines of Banks by introduction
of prudential norms and transparency in balance sheet.
This reform process has seen several
banks posting losses and some of them having their capital base eroded
completely. But after initial pangs, banks are eventually coming to terms
with having to survive in a competitive market and are looking lot more
healthier than they were in the years of total control.
The twin objectives of operational
flexibility and financial autonomy have been largely achieved so as to
continuously enhance efficiency, productivity and profitability of the
banks.
The public sector banks as a group
registered a strong turnaround from net loss of 3.71 billion in 1995-96
to a net profit of nearly 31 billion in 1996-97. Their operating profit
also showed a rise to 88.88 billion and the level of net NPA fell to 9.1%
by March, 1997. Net inflow of non-resident deposits recorded a three fold
increase in 1996-97, reflecting increased confidence in the economic performance.
Six years through the reform process indicates that the banking sector
has apparently responded well to it.
Banks can look back with satisfaction
at having responded effectively to the challenges posed before them from
time to time- whether of social control or of reforms.
To sum up, banks will have to adjust
their systems of functioning, venture into new areas, improve efficiency
levels by inclusion of trained and skilled manpower and restructure their
organisations. Only then they can face the challenges of the future more
confidently and proactively.
-
What are the ill-effects of bank
nationalisation ?
Nationalisation of bank aimed, inter
alia, at mobilisation of vast resources of the country, and simultaneously
to channelise the same for higher productivity in a shortest possible time
and to make the banking facilities widely available to the large section
of the people. The nationalised banks were explicitly set quantitative
targets to expand their network in semi-urban and rural areas and to direct
credit to the priority sectors. Over a period of time, these banks became
a major source of lending to the Government, and thus meeting the fiscal
deficits. There was a dramatic expansion of Banks' branches throughout
the country. Many of the branches though were unprofitable, but they did
play a positive role in mopping up financial savings. The inflation remained
reasonably low and real interest rates were only marginally negative. However,
bank nationalisation was not free from its ill-effects. There was directed
allocation of resources towards low productive assets (both credit and
investment). As a result, the country had erected unprofitable and unsound
financial sector.
The average return on assets was
extremely low with the massive growth of branch expansion and the quality
of service deteriorated. The real health of the banks could not be assessed,
because of unscientific accounting procedure and the banking sector not
having prudential norms to maintain its financial discipline. The banking
industry was loaded with huge Non-performing Assets and per employee business
dropped substantially.
-
How do you see the Banking Industry
responding to the changes ?
The economic reforms initiated by the
Government of India in early 90s have brought a sea change in operational
environment of financial sector, its functioning and outlook of Indian
banks. The Indian Banking Industry has been undergoing a metamorphosis
since the commencing of liberalisation in 1991 following the recommendation
of the Narashimham Committee on the financial system. Measures like :
-
Reduction in Reserve requirements
-
Deregulation of interest rate
-
Introduction of prudential norms relating
to capital adequacy, income recognition, assets classification and provisioning
-
Liberalisation of banks' licensing policy
etc.
-
Forced the Banks to re-look at their
business strategies
-
Opening up of doors to private sector
banks and foreign banks have added to the competition
The financial markets will be continually
characterised by four, significant trends, viz., financial liberalisation,
disintermediation, internationalisation and technological advancement.
Financial liberalisation leads to
the rise of nonbanks like finance companies, mutual funds, investment banks,
insurance companies and even non-financial firms as purveyors of liquidity
and risk management services.
Disintermediation erodes banks'
share and role because banks evolved within a culture of very cautions
credit risk-taking. This culture has been encouraged or even demanded by
regulators for which banks have erected expensive credit, audit and risk
management departments. The rise of secondary markets for bank loans not
only helps to satisfy the liquidity needs of non-traditional investors
but also conscripts banks' role.
Internationalisation is a result
of liberalisation and disintermediation. It encourages consolidation and
concentration within the industry.
Indian Banking is on major technological
upgradation drive after having successfully absorbed the international
standard in their operating norms. It is commonly perceived that technology
is important to enhance the quality of customer service and to make it
customer-friendly; it will also improve the operational efficiency and
productivity. Banks are expected to use all new technological developments
in the field of computerisation and communication.
-
How do you see the Banking Industry
in the new millennium ?
The transformation of the financial
system in the new decade is certainly not beyond capabilities of Indian
Banking Industry. The industry has enormous strength in the system alongside
weaknesses. A highly talented manpower is definitely a potential asset,
they only need to be motivated. In the year 2000 and beyond, it is definite
that the banking industry has to strive very hard to achieve significant
increase in productivity, efficiency and profitability in the competitive
banking scenario.
They should maintain capital adequacy
ratio prescribed by the Government and to meet their credit portfolio free
from contamination so as to acquire quality assets.
The nationalised banks in particular
have to go long way towards professionalisation in their operations to
build up public confidence in banking system. The Banking Industry has
to play active role to its Assets Liabilities Management to reduce risk
and simultaneously to improve its profitability.
In the quest of providing better
and efficient customer service a technological revolution is a must in
the Indian Banking Sector.
Indian Banks have already experienced
the impact of partial convertibility and marching ahead to play an important
role in the challenging environment which is bound to surface out no sooner
full convertibility comes into effect. The Financial Institutions in India
are going to play a pivotal role in the Globalised Economy. Indian Market
with its enormous potential will be a centre of interest of the World community
and Indian Banks have to find their places in this competitive scenario.
It is the performing banks who will
survive and those who are unable to keep pace with the changed scenario
and unable to respond quickly to fast changes would be left behind in the
race.
-
This year as a whole bank's financial
results were better than expected - what do you attribute ?
The key reasons attributed for achieving
comparatively better results during this year by the Banking Industry as
a whole were as under :
-
The average call money rate normally
remained below 8 to 9% throughout the year and Banks enjoyed better spread
both in advance and investment portfolios.
-
Reduction of CRR resulted into better
liquidity due to announcement of YTM at a favourable rate on Governments
securities.
-
Average deposit growth of the industry
was around 20%. The inflation rate was contained at around 6%.
-
Better Credit off take by the Industries
in the second half of the financial year.
-
Better performance in the area of recovery.
-
Most of the Banks improved their non-interest
income.
-
But priority sector credit targets
have not been met in many cases-what is the reason behind this ?
The reasons are primarily
-
Huge accumulation of NPA
-
Poor recovery
-
Fear of accountability on the part of
the banks' officials
-
Political interference in Credit disbursements
-
The spread available in lending is low
-
Available securities are not adequate
to cover facilities extended by the bank
-
High cost of stamp duties for creating
mortgage of land and properties to be placed as security to the Bank
-
Long drawn legal process for recovery
of Bank dues
-
Book-keeping/record maintenance are
not professionally done-as a result the health of the unit sometimes cannot
be ascertained
-
Susceptibility of the unit becoming
sick is due to poor infrastructural facilities and uncertain market demands.
-
Do you think the uncertain political
climate has hindered the development and unshackling of the banking sector
in India ?
Changes in political climate alter the
development process of Banking sector. When we aim at improving the financial
system to international standards, it is necessary that supporting sub-systems
like legal and labour laws, economic policies and environment confirm to
international standards. These receive set back due to political uncertainties.
-
What is your opinion about `Open
Economy of India' ?
As of now the Indian Economy does not
seem ready for `Open Economy' condition. After witnessing the economic
crisis in South East Asian Countries it has been realised that without
having a stable economic growth it is difficult for any developing countries
to go in for free economy leading to capital account convertibility of
the currency. India is now passing through a phase of liberalisation and
is tightening its financial reforms. It is also to be understood that the
financial reform already undertaken by India is irreversible and it is
a matter of time only when these are implemented completely. We may definitely
look for an `Open Economy' when we can visualise a situation where India's
-
Current account deficit has been pegged
at 2% of GDP
-
GDP growth is 6% and above
-
Exports have been growing at an annual
rate of 17% in dollar terms;
-
Non-oil import growth rate has stabilised
at around 15% in dollar terms
-
The country's foreign exchange reserves
are equivalent to say 6 month's import requirement
-
Interest rate is in line with international
level of interest rate and
-
Inflation rate is contained below 3%
-
Any comments on Government Policy
?
Since no specific policy is mentioned,
it is difficult to comment on this issue. However, so far as financial
system is concerned, laws relating to recovery of loans, documentation,
disposal of cases in courts and many other areas need to be reviewed and
upgraded. Similarly, labour laws need to be amended to ensure higher productivity.
In all these areas, as yet, no clear policy indicators are visible. As
such, there are uncertainties and therefore, halting growth of the system.
-
Do you have any observation on
any other issues ?
No other particular issue comes to force
at present. I am thankful to the editors of the magazine for giving an
opportunity to express my views on the financial system of the country.
While supporting the financial and
economic structure of our country. |