Role of Urban Informal Sector
in Economic Growth
By Subhashis Mitra
Urban informal sector
contributes significantly to the growth of the economy. This becomes more
pertinent in view of the fact that there has been a decrease in employment
in the formal sector.
The role of the
informal sector is increasing day by day as more and more workers are getting
retrenched in the formal sector. Under this grim backdrop, a National Workshop
was held in the capital recently on Street Vendors and Hawkers, who are
creating their own employment without putting any burden on the government.
Taking into consideration the contribution made by hawkers and street vendors,
the government is actively considering a proposal to draw up policies and
schemes to ameliorate their condition.
At the workshop,
which called for setting up of a Task Force to finalise the Guidelines
for Street Vending, the then Minister for Urban Development and Poverty
Alleviation, Mr Jagmohan, emphasised the need for continuous dialogue among
street vendors, urban local bodies, police and Resident's Welfare Association.
As such, the Task
Force will include representatives of vendors associations and urban local
bodies. The workshop, jointly organised by the Ministry of Urban Development
and Poverty Alleviation and Self Employed Women's Association (SEWA), urged
all urban local bodies to recognise the important contribution of street
vendors and to draw up policies and schemes which will incorporate them
into the urban economy and life.
Recognising that
street vendors have always been part of the Indian urban culture of public
spaces and services, the Workshop noted that the urban informal sector
contributed significantly to the growth of the economy. It further observed
that the street vendors remained poor and illiterate and were treated as
illegal persons and also as criminals and harassed by police and municipal
authorities, and excluded from all town-planning schemes.
Therefore, with
a view to bringing these one crore street vendors into the mainstream of
the urban economy, the Workshop recommended that the policy of the urban
local body should be to regulate street vending and to provide them specific
places and specific time for vending. Their location and work should be
regulated by a suitable mechanism recognising their role in urban life.
While recommending
legal recognition of street vendors by giving them identity cards, State
governments and urban local bodies should plan guidelines to reserve certain
percentage of land for street vendors in all development plans and to update
existing plans.
Guidelines should
decide number of vendors required as a percentage of population .and plan
the number of vendors to be accommodated accordingly. Besides, priority
should be given to women vendors in issuing permission for hawking and
vending.
Setting up of self-governance
mechanisms such as committees and boards was also suggested by the Workshop
so that they could work closely with the municipality to harmonies the
interests of all parties the vendors, the shopkeepers, the residents, the
consumers and the traffic.
Keeping in mind
the poor economic condition of the street vendors, there is the need to
promote credit schemes and micro-finance for the vendors.
Referring to this
aspect, Mr Jagmohan indicated that a provision may be, made in the 10th
Five Year Plan to provide street vendors with meaningful access to institutional
credit and financial services to that they are not left at the mercy of
private money-lenders and loan sharks. He said that grant of financial
help may also be considered for groups of vendors from Swarn Jayanti Shahari
Rozgar Yojana if they form cooperatives. Yet, regulation of vendors is
not an easy task due to heavy influx of low skilled migrants seeking employment
in the cities and due to growing urban indiscipline.
While the original
Master Plan of Delhi had earmarked five per cent area for hawkers and vendors,
this never worked in reality because hawkers allotted the area preferred
to sell it to others and move elsewhere.
According to a report
based on a recent study of hawkers and street vendors conducted in seven
cities of India by the National Alliance of Street Vendors of India (NASVI)
these people generally possessed low skills and lacked the level of education
required for the better paid jobs in the organised sector. For these people
work in the informal sector are the only means for their survival.
The report said
that for the urban poor, hawking is one of the means of earning a livelihood
as it requires minor financial input and the skills involved are low.
Studies conducted
in the metropolises of Mumbai, Ahmedabad, and Collate reveal that these
people, or their spouses, were once engaged in better paid jobs in the
formal sector. Most of them were employed in the textile mills in Mumbai
and Ahmedabad and in engineering firms in Collate. Formal sector workers
in these three metropolises have had to face large-scale unemployment due
to the closure of these industries. Hence, many of them, or their wives
have become street vendors in order to eke out a living.
The study conducted
by Prof. Sharit Bhowmick, Head of the Department of Sociology, University
of Mumbai, reveals that Mumbai has the largest number of hawkers
numbering around 200,000. Kolkata has more than 100,000 hawkers. Ahmedabad
and Patna have around 80,000 each and Indore, Bangalore and Bhubaneswar
have around 30,000 hawkers.
An important aspect
that should not be overlooked is the fact that the total employment provided
through hawking becomes larger if we consider the scenario that they sustain
certain industries by providing markets for their products. A lot of goods
sold by hawkers, such as clothes and hosiery, leather and moulded plastic
goods and household goods, are manufactured in small scale or home-based
Industries. These industries employ large number of workers and the manufacturers
could have hardly marketed their products on their own. In this way they
provide a valuable service by helping sustain employment in these industries.
(By Arrangement with Kaleidoscope)
|